| Event | Date | Location | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs St. Peters Peacocks | Fri. Nov 13, 2009 7:00PM | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center |  |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Long Island Blackbirds | Sat. Nov 28, 2009 8:00PM | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs New Jersey Tech | Mon. Nov 30, 2009 7:00PM | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Hartford Hawks | Thu. Dec 3, 2009 7:00PM | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs UMass Minutemen | Mon. Dec 7, 2009 7:00PM | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Virginia Military Keydets | Sat. Dec 12, 2009 12:00PM | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Temple Owls | Sat. Dec 19, 2009 7:00PM | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Navy Midshipmen | Tue. Dec 22, 2009 7:00PM | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs West Virginia Mountaineers | Sat. Dec 26, 2009 3:30PM | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Syracuse Orange | Tue. Dec 29, 2009 TBA | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| UConn Huskies vs Seton Hall Pirates | Wed. Jan 6, 2010 9:00PM | Storrs Mansfield, CT - Gampel Pavilion | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Cincinnati Bearcats | Sat. Jan 9, 2010 TBA | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Georgetown Hoyas vs Seton Hall Pirates | Thu. Jan 14, 2010 7:00PM | Washington, DC - Verizon Center - DC | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Louisville Cardinals | Thu. Jan 21, 2010 TBA | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Pittsburgh Panthers | Sun. Jan 24, 2010 TBA | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Villanova Wildcats vs Seton Hall Pirates | Tue. Feb 2, 2010 TBA | Villanova, PA - The Pavilion At Villanova | |
| Pittsburgh Panthers vs Seton Hall Pirates | Sat. Feb 6, 2010 6:00PM | Pittsburgh, PA - Petersen Events Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Notre Dame Fighting Irish | Thu. Feb 11, 2010 TBA | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Depaul Blue Demons | Sun. Feb 14, 2010 TBA | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| St. Johns Red Storm vs Seton Hall Pirates | Wed. Feb 17, 2010 7:30PM | Jamaica, NY - Carnesecca Arena | |
| West Virginia Mountaineers vs Seton Hall Pirates | Sat. Feb 20, 2010 TBA | Morgantown, WV - West Virginia University Coliseum | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Rutgers Scarlet Knights | Tue. Feb 23, 2010 TBA | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Seton Hall Pirates vs Marquette Golden Eagles | Sun. Feb 28, 2010 TBA | Newark, NJ - Prudential Center | |
| Providence Friars vs Seton Hall Pirates | Sat. Mar 6, 2010 7:00PM | Providence, RI - Dunkin Donuts Center | |
